Greek Food, Cooking and Recipe Community

Making a Traditional Pastitsio - Tips?

1 - 2 of 2 Posts
A

acamp7

Active member
I’m trying to make pastitsio using my family’s recipe, but it’s one of those classic Greek recipes—vague instructions, no exact measurements, and lots of “you’ll know when it’s right.” ? I’ve made it a few times, but I feel like something is missing, so I could use some tips.

I am having trouble with the béchamel sauce and getting the seasonings right in the meat. I put so much cinnamon last time it tasted bitter - but my family recipe said to put a lot and didn't explain how much. The Bechemel had a gummy texture.

I want to get it as close to the way my family did it but I feel like I didn't make it enough with the people "in the know" so I am missing some technical understanding.
 
Pastitsio is one of those dishes where every family has their own “correct” way! For the béchamel, a gummy texture usually means too much flour or overcooking. Try a 1:1:10 ratio—1 part butter, 1 part flour, 10 parts milk. Whisk the flour and butter for at least 2 minutes to cook off the raw taste, then slowly add warm milk, whisking constantly. Off the heat, add one beaten egg for richness and fluffiness.

For the meat sauce, cinnamon is key, but a little goes a long way. Start with ¼ teaspoon per pound of meat, along with allspice or nutmeg for balance. Also, make sure to simmer the sauce long enough to mellow the flavors.
 
1 - 2 of 2 Posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION AND READ OTHER GREEK INFO:

Meat to Use for Souvlaki?

I’ve been trying to make souvlaki at home more often, and I keep going back and forth on what meat to use. I’ve had great pork souvlaki that felt like what you’d get in Greece, but I’ve also had chicken versions that were really solid and easy to cook. Lamb seems like it should work well too, but I don’t see it used as often for souvlaki specifically. And then there’s beef, which I’ve seen here and there but never really know if it’s the right choice.

Is there a “best” meat for souvlaki, or is it more about how it’s prepared and seasoned? Do certain meats hold up better on the grill or stay juicier?

Gemista: meat or no meat?

I’ve been thinking about gemista lately, especially with Lent going on and all the fasting days we have throughout the year. It feels like one of those dishes that really works both ways.

Sometimes I actually prefer it without meat—the rice, herbs, olive oil, and vegetables come together in such a clean, flavorful way. Other times, though, I really enjoy it with meat, especially when it’s baked long enough for everything to blend together.

I grew up seeing it made both ways, so to me it never felt like one “right” version. It just depends on the mood, the season, or even who’s cooking.

I’m curious how others feel about this. Do you have a strong preference for meat or no meat? Or do you switch between the two depending on the time of year or occasion?

Favorite Greek Seafood Dishes

I’ve been trying to branch out more with Greek seafood dishes lately and realized I tend to stick to the same few options. Grilled fish with ladolemono, shrimp saganaki, and fried calamari are usually my defaults, but I know there’s a lot more out there depending on the region and what’s in season.

I’m curious what everyone here gravitates toward. Do you prefer something simple like whole grilled fish, or dishes that are a bit more composed, like seafood stews or baked recipes? Are there any specific island or coastal specialties that stand out to you?

Also interested in how you prepare seafood at home. Do you keep it minimal with olive oil, lemon, and herbs, or do you follow more traditional recipes? Would love to hear what your go-to Greek seafood dishes are!

Most popular dishes of Greece?

I was talking to someone yesterday and mentioned that fasolada is considered one of the “national dishes of Greece”. I’m pretty sure I’ve heard that somewhere before. But it got me thinking, what actually are the most popular dishes in Greece?

I feel like everyone immediately thinks of things like moussaka or souvlaki, and maybe even horiatiki salad, but I’m not sure if those are the most commonly eaten foods in everyday life or just the most well-known internationally.

Are there certain dishes that Greeks themselves would consider staples or “must-haves”? And does it vary a lot by region? What dishes come to mind when you think of what is popular in Greece?

How much garlic is too much in tzatziki?

When I grill Greek-style, I usually serve everything with tzatziki on the side, souvlaki, chicken, even just some bread and vegetables. For me, it’s not really optional. It kind of ties the whole plate together.

That said, I’ve noticed everyone seems to have a different tolerance for garlic. Some tzatziki is nice and balanced, while other times it’s so strong it completely takes over everything else on the plate.

I tend to like a good amount of garlic, but I’ve definitely had versions where it felt like a bit much, especially if it’s sitting overnight and the flavor gets stronger.

Curious where everyone else lands on this. Do you go heavy on the garlic, or do you keep it more subtle? And do you adjust depending on what you’re serving it with?
Sign up for a free account and share your thoughts, photos, questions about Greek food, travel and culture!

WorldwideGreeks.com is a free online forum community where people can discuss Greek food, travel, traditions, history and mythology.
Join Worldwide Greeks here!

JOIN COMMUNITY FOR FREE

LOGIN TO YOUR ACCOUNT
Back
Top