Greek Food, Cooking and Recipe Community

Pastitsio - Should I Add Cinnamon?

1 - 4 of 4 Posts
d_kakavouli

d_kakavouli

Active member
Hi everyone! I’m making pastitsio this weekend for a family gathering, and I’m debating whether or not to add cinnamon to the meat sauce. I’ve seen it both ways—some recipes call for just a pinch, while others go heavier, giving it that sweet, aromatic depth. I know cinnamon is more common in moussaka, but I’ve heard it’s traditional in pastitsio too, depending on the region.

What do you all think? Does cinnamon make it more authentic, or do you prefer a more savory meat sauce without the sweetness? I’m leaning toward adding just a bit, but I don’t want to overwhelm anyone who’s expecting something more classic and hearty. Do you do nutmeg and cinnamon both? I usually put nutmeg in the béchamel.
 
Kali Anastasi,

Anytime, I use tomato paste/sauce then I use cinnamon but not too much. I do the same with the nutmeg in my béchamel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Greek Vibe
Great question! Cinnamon is definitely traditional in many Greek pastitsio recipes—it adds that warm, nostalgic depth that a lot of people associate with classic Greek comfort food. That said, balance is key. I usually go with a small pinch of cinnamon in the meat sauce—just enough to give it that aromatic note without making it taste sweet. If you’re already using nutmeg in the béchamel (which I do too), a light hand with the cinnamon helps the layers complement each other without competing.

Some cooks also add a tiny bit of allspice or clove, but again, just a touch. If you’re serving a crowd and unsure about their preferences, I’d say err on the side of subtlety—you can always add more next time if they love it! A hint of cinnamon really brings out the richness of the meat sauce without overpowering it. Sounds like it’ll be a delicious gathering!
 
The best idea would be to add a cinnamon stick while making your bechamel. Then take it out once it's creamy. That way it won't be too strong. also add a cinnamon stick while making the meat stew (kima). and yes a touch of nutmeg is also a great. Good luck
 
1 - 4 of 4 Posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION AND READ OTHER GREEK INFO:

How do you cook okra without it turning slimy?

I grew up eating bamies all summer long in Greece, and it’s still one of my favorite dishes, especially when cooked with onions, tomatoes, and a touch of olive oil. But even after years of making it here in the U.S., I can’t seem to find a consistent way to keep the okra from turning slimy. Sometimes it comes out perfect, tender and flavorful with no stickiness, and other times it gets that slippery texture no matter what I do.

I’ve heard different tricks over the years: soaking in vinegar, roasting before stewing, not stirring too much, or using smaller pods. But none of them seem to work every time.

For those of you who also love traditional Greek bamies, what’s your secret? Is it all about the freshness of the okra, or is there a step in the cooking process that really makes the difference?

How do you make your tzatziki creamier?

I make Greek food all the time, spanakopita, keftedes, souvlaki, you name it — but I’ve always taken the shortcut and bought my tzatziki ready-made. Lately I’ve been wanting to make it from scratch and get that rich, creamy texture you find in good tavernas.

I’ve tried a few recipes with strained Greek yogurt, grated cucumber, garlic, olive oil, and lemon juice, but mine keeps turning out too thin or slightly watery after a few hours. I strain the cucumber and even use full-fat yogurt, but it still doesn’t have that thick, velvety consistency.

So I’m curious — what’s your secret to creamier tzatziki? Do you use a specific brand of yogurt, or maybe add something like sour cream or labneh? Does chilling it overnight make a difference? I’d love to hear how you make yours stay thick, fresh, and perfectly balanced between tangy and smooth.

Avgolemono Soup - Rice or Orzo?

I’ve been making avgolemono for years, but I recently noticed how divided people are on one simple choice: rice or orzo.

I grew up eating it with rice, and I love how it thickens the broth slightly and makes the soup feel like comfort in a bowl. But I’ve also tried versions with orzo that feel a bit lighter and silkier — almost like a cross between soup and pasta.

Some recipes swear by short-grain rice for that creamy texture, while others argue orzo gives better control so the eggs don’t curdle. I’ve even seen a few cooks skip both and make a pure broth version!

So I’m curious, which do you use, and why? Is it a regional thing, a family tradition, or just personal taste?

What pasta do you use for pastritsio?

I usually use the long, hollow macaroni no.2 from Greece when I make pastitsio. It’s the classic kind that gives you those perfect layers that I love. The problem is, I can’t always find it locally, and ordering online isn’t always convenient (or quick).

When I don’t have it on hand, I start to panic a bit. Pastitsio just doesn’t feel the same without the right pasta! I’ve tried ziti, penne, and even bucatini in a pinch, but nothing seems to hold up quite like the Greek version. I’m curious what everyone else does when they can’t find the real thing.

Do you have a favorite substitute that still gives that authentic texture? Or do you swear by only using the traditional Greek macaroni? I’d love to hear what’s worked for others, especially if you’ve discovered any good brands available in the U.S.

Greek things to do with butternut squash?

Hi everyone! I’m curious about traditional (or regional) Greek ways to cook with butternut squash. My aunt used to make an incredible kolokythopita with it — sweet, earthy, and a little reminiscent of butternut squash pie filling, but wrapped in crisp phyllo instead of a pastry crust. It was one of those dishes that tasted both rustic and festive at the same time.

I’m wondering what else Greeks typically do with butternut squash, especially in home cooking. Are there savory versions of the pie? Any stews, ladera, or casseroles that feature it? Does anyone use it in soups, risottos, or baked dishes? I’d also love to know if certain regions in Greece cook with butternut squash more often than others.

Would love to hear your ideas, family recipes, and regional traditions!
Sign up for a free account and share your thoughts, photos, questions about Greek food, travel and culture!

WorldwideGreeks.com is a free online forum community where people can discuss Greek food, travel, traditions, history and mythology.
Join Worldwide Greeks here!

JOIN COMMUNITY FOR FREE

LOGIN TO YOUR ACCOUNT
Back
Top