Greek Food, Cooking and Recipe Community

What makes the perfect pastitsio?

1 - 2 of 2 Posts
M

mastichas09

Active member
I know everyone’s got their own way of making pastitsio, and I’m curious what you all think makes it perfect. I’m Greek and have been making it for years, but I swear every family has a different take, even just within my circle of friends, no two versions are the same!

For me, the key is a good, fluffy krema on top, which makes it not too dense, not too thin — and a meat layer that’s rich but not overly heavy. I also like just a hint of tomato sauce mixed in with the meat; it gives it depth and color without turning it into makaronia me kima.

Do you prefer a spiced meat sauce or something milder? Do you bake it until it’s firm or leave it soft and creamy? I’d love to hear your tricks, family secrets, and regional twists!
 
I completely agree that no two pastitsia are ever quite the same, even within one household! In my family, my grandmother’s version came from northern Greece and always had a strong hint of cinnamon and clove in the meat layer, while my mother toned that down over the years to make it more savory and balanced. I’ve kept the lighter hand with spices but added my own twist: a mix of ground beef and pork for depth and a splash of white wine in the sauce.

For the krema, I aim for that same “fluffy but firm” texture you described, whisking the eggs in slowly and adding just a touch of nutmeg. I bake mine until the top turns a golden crust, but the inside still has that creamy give when sliced. It’s comfort food perfection, every bite feels like home!
 
1 - 2 of 2 Posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION AND READ OTHER GREEK INFO:

What Are You Baking This Holiday Season?

Every holiday season, my kitchen fills with the smell of butter, honey, and toasted nuts, it’s not Christmas without a tray (or three!) of melomakarona and kourabiedes cooling on the counter. I still remember rolling them by hand with my yiayia and dusting everything in sugar until the whole room sparkled.

Now that I bake on my own, I’ve started adding little twists, a drizzle of dark chocolate on the melomakarona, or orange zest in the dough. Some years I even make tsoureki for the holidays instead of waiting for Easter.

I’m curious — what are your Greek holiday baking traditions? Do you stay loyal to the classic recipes, or try modern variations? Any family stories behind your favorite sweets? I’d love to hear what’s in your oven this season and which recipes you can’t celebrate without.

How do you make your tzatziki creamier?

I make Greek food all the time, spanakopita, keftedes, souvlaki, you name it — but I’ve always taken the shortcut and bought my tzatziki ready-made. Lately I’ve been wanting to make it from scratch and get that rich, creamy texture you find in good tavernas.

I’ve tried a few recipes with strained Greek yogurt, grated cucumber, garlic, olive oil, and lemon juice, but mine keeps turning out too thin or slightly watery after a few hours. I strain the cucumber and even use full-fat yogurt, but it still doesn’t have that thick, velvety consistency.

So I’m curious — what’s your secret to creamier tzatziki? Do you use a specific brand of yogurt, or maybe add something like sour cream or labneh? Does chilling it overnight make a difference? I’d love to hear how you make yours stay thick, fresh, and perfectly balanced between tangy and smooth.

Favorite Herbs for Dolmades?

I’ve been experimenting with different herb combinations for dolmades lately, and I’m curious what everyone else uses. Traditionally I’ve seen recipes with dill, parsley, mint, or even a mix of all three — but I’ve found that mint really makes the flavor pop. It gives the filling such a fresh, aromatic lift that balances the rice and olive oil beautifully.

Sometimes I’ll add a touch of dill for depth, or parsley if I want something more earthy, but mint always seems to bring everything together. I’ve also noticed some regions lean heavily on dill, while others skip it entirely.

Do you find that certain herbs make your dolmades taste more authentic or closer to how your family used to make them? Do you adjust depending on whether they’re meat-filled or vegetarian?

Greek things to do with butternut squash?

Hi everyone! I’m curious about traditional (or regional) Greek ways to cook with butternut squash. My aunt used to make an incredible kolokythopita with it — sweet, earthy, and a little reminiscent of butternut squash pie filling, but wrapped in crisp phyllo instead of a pastry crust. It was one of those dishes that tasted both rustic and festive at the same time.

I’m wondering what else Greeks typically do with butternut squash, especially in home cooking. Are there savory versions of the pie? Any stews, ladera, or casseroles that feature it? Does anyone use it in soups, risottos, or baked dishes? I’d also love to know if certain regions in Greece cook with butternut squash more often than others.

Would love to hear your ideas, family recipes, and regional traditions!

Do you ever mix traditional Greek recipes with modern twists?

I grew up cooking traditional Greek food. All the recipes in my kitchen are ones that have been passed down through my family.

I still make them exactly as they were written most of the time, but every now and then, I can’t help experimenting a little. I’ll swap ingredients, lighten things up, or try a more modern cooking method just to see how it turns out.

The funny thing is, even when the newer versions taste amazing, there’s still something about the old recipes that feels different. Maybe it’s the memories attached to them, such as the smells, the sounds, the people around the table.

I’m curious how others feel about this. Do you ever mix traditional Greek recipes with modern twists? Do you think it changes the soul of the dish, or do you see it as keeping our food culture alive and evolving?
Sign up for a free account and share your thoughts, photos, questions about Greek food, travel and culture!

WorldwideGreeks.com is a free online forum community where people can discuss Greek food, travel, traditions, history and mythology.
Join Worldwide Greeks here!

JOIN COMMUNITY FOR FREE

LOGIN TO YOUR ACCOUNT
Back
Top