1. A

    Do you think Helen of Troy was abducted? Or did she escape willingly with Paris?

    There is no single story; the contradictory stories imply agnosticism. So, I ask myself, was there ever a Helen [related to the historical war] ? According to one myth, Helen was the daughter of Zeus. I infer that if he is mythic in nature so is she. Why a Helen? //... to EXPLAIN the...
  2. A

    Prove the mythological gods do not exist

    they believed in deities for some reasons! they, i think, were not irrational believers.... i asked these questions to hear from contemporary Greek philosophers/thinkers -- you and you [reader]
  3. A

    Getting into the mindset of Ancient Greek religion

    I like the phrase, "... and their ways of seeing the world". Lately I have been considering the phrasing of the nature of their gods according to their mindset/perspective/frame-of-mind, in comparison to other mindsets. Result: A Greek myth-maker typically looked at a relationship between a...
  4. A

    Prove the mythological gods do not exist

    The question whether they exist or not is a philosophical question , which applies a fortiori [all the more] to the belief in one GOD, whether it is called ZEUS or simply THEOS. Update: Theodosius banished polytheism and, unwittingly, any theism. The Christian iconoclasts did the same. Why...
  5. A

    Prove the mythological gods do not exist

    I have already replied...... Sorry again; your perspective does not prove or disprove the existence of gods,
  6. A

    Is Persephone the Greek goddess of spring?

    My outlook in brief: Demeter is the grain-vegetation goddess. In the vegetable kingdom, reproduction is asexual -- by seeds/grains or spores. Demeter's young one [korE/kora/Cora] was abducted by Hades. Hence her grief etc. ... Zeus compromise: she is to share parts of the year with him and with...
  7. A

    Eros the God of Love

    xmelissa, it's not just you; it's a very old tradition to SPEAK in this manner: the god OF love, the father OF the Olympians, etc. Thus it seems that love and the god are distinct. No, EROS = love, but as personified, it is called a god. As a drive, Socrates called it a Daimon. Chronos =...
  8. A

    Prove the mythological gods do not exist

    or that they exist
  9. A

    Eros the God of Love

    To add: Even though Plato was not a physicist, in his Symposium he dealt with human love in the context of Love/Eros as the cosmic principle of attraction, which was recognized by the elementarists [Empedocles etc.].
  10. A

    Eros the God of Love

    Well, yes and no.... IF a male seeks his other half, eros is a driving force. This is the inevitable concept of it, which has been called also LOVE. I am reminded of the words in La Traviata: ...di quell'AMOR ch'e` palpito dell'universo intero: ...of that LOVE which is the palpitation...
  11. A

    History of the Orthodox Church in Greece

    All of you, Above Writers, do well in pointing out that, for example, Letters in the NT were addressed to newly formed Xian communities/churches [Ephesus, Corinth, etc.], but unfortunately did not refer to sources about the other half of the organized religion, namely the liturgy -- e.g., the...
  12. A

    The Spartans: An Ancient War Machine.

    thank for posting this URL, which leads to "related posts", including the one about Nikos Kazantzakis. Of course, I have seen Zorba the Greek ..... and cherished his THE LAST TEMPTATION OF CHRIST. [many years ago, my book was borrowed and never returned]
  13. A

    Eros the God of Love

    Going from the Age of Myths to the Age of Reason: Plato sees that eros is a man's DESIRE for the other half -- obviously referring to the ancient myth that "Anthropos" [grammatically either masculine of feminine -- ho/hE -- in classical Greek] was split into two parts. Sorry, this myth has to be...
  14. A

    Could the Parthenon marbles be returned to Greece?

    It is the dream of every nation to have its stolen artifacts returned, but consider these days when countries like Greece, Italy, etc., are being occupied by foreign hoodlums who are bent on destroying their artistic heritage! Artifacts in foreign museums are well kept and, I suppose, are best...
  15. A

    Geographical Images of the Gods

    Sorry to have to say this. The Greek gods were conceived long before their artistic representations, but no proof of this. The conceivers or imaginers of the gods did NOT have geo. knowledge or maps such as you have. Your research was pointless.
  16. A

    Topics to Study in Greek History?

    Good suggestions... On this occasion, I searched "the cult of Athena". A good read: https://www.worldhistory.org/article/74 namely: "The Women of Athena's Cult"
  17. A

    Topics to Study in Greek History?

    I, too, love learning about Greek history, especially the ancient one , and specifically the obviously frequent communications of the various populations [tribes] of the Greek ecoumene from Asia Minor [Ionia etc.] to South Italy [Magna Graecia and Sicily]. A recent good read with illustrations...
  18. A

    Most interesting stories of Greek mythology?

    When you read the Iliad, the Odyssey or any other book, can you tell what is myth and what is fact? Now that you are at it, should read also the Hebrew Bible, or. to stay within Greek matters, the Gospels, which were composed in [not translated into] Greek.
  19. A

    Getting into the mindset of Ancient Greek religion

    One necessary addition: after the personification of superhumanly powerful things and events [hence the gods], the ancients saw them as immortal, whereas humans are mortal. Typically the ancient Greeks, had the feeling of this tragic disparity and sought immortality. Hence the rise of various...
  20. A

    Getting into the mindset of Ancient Greek religion

    The big and eternal question for everybody to begin with; WHAT IS RELIGION? An old view: ti's a man's active relationship to a supernatural power which, I add, was personified. etc. Some such powers are destructvive, harmful. Response: seeking to propitiate it; begging to be spared, etc...
Back
Top