Greek History Community

How did Hellenists gamble, divine or play with these rare ancient bones found in Israel?

1 - 10 of 10 Posts
Hash

Hash

Well-known member
I see it's been a while since you've posted, but I just want to ask—do we know if these astragali were used more for games like knucklebones or more for divination? I've read they were often marked with symbols, which makes me wonder if people trusted them to guide decisions, kind of like how we flip coins today. Anyone come across examples from other Hellenistic sites?
 
I actually saw something similar on a doc once—people used knucklebones like dice, kinda like how we use them in board games now. It’s wild thinking about how gambling or even fortune-telling had such physical tools. I looked into recently while trying to figure out which modern platforms are safe to use for stuff like that, and it helped me avoid some sketchy sites pretending to offer legit services.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I see it’s been a while since you’ve posted, but I just want to ask—has anyone come across similar artifacts tied to Greek rituals outside of Israel? I’ve read about knucklebones turning up in Italy and Egypt too. Wondering if anyone’s compared how they were used across regions—were they more for games, divination, or something else entirely depending on location?
 
Could’ve been a mix of gambling and some form of fortune telling—people have been finding ways to make a game out of chance for thousands of years. I’ve read about ancient dice games that weren’t far off from what we do today. Makes me think of the light betting I do on https://www.beaufortpirateinvasion.com/ , just with a modern twist instead of carved bones.
 
I see it's been a while since this thread was active, but I just want to ask—has anyone come across any more recent findings or studies about how these knucklebones were used? I'm curious whether they were more for everyday fun, like a game, or had a sacred, divinatory purpose. It feels like the line between gambling and rituals could have been blurry in ancient times.
 
I’ve seen similar bone dice in museums, and it’s wild to think they were used for both games and maybe fortune-telling. Ancient gambling hasn’t changed much—just the tools have. These days, I’ve found sites like non-ukcasinos.org helpful for comparing options for places that don’t fall under UK restrictions. Makes me wonder how ancient games evolved into what we consider modern betting.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I saw something similar recently on a documentary, they used knucklebones like dice, either for games or even divination. It's wild how something that looks random ends up having deeper meaning.

I was searching for accessories to match that kind of old-school vibe for a costume and ended up finding some cool pieces on armadiofashion.com that had that ancient, timeless look. Definitely worth browsing if you're into that aesthetic.
 
Last edited:
Hellenistic astragali are fascinating because they seem to serve dual purposes. Evidence from various sites suggests they were used both as gaming pieces, similar to knucklebones or dice, and for divination, with symbols possibly guiding decisions or predicting outcomes. It’s interesting to see how a single object could blend entertainment and ritual in daily life. Have any other examples been found showing clear symbolic markings?
 
I find it fascinating how these bones served dual purposes for games and divination. It makes me think of modern betting platforms that blend entertainment with strategy. I regularly use go-to the website for online sabong, and the secure transactions and live streams work well for me.
 
1 - 10 of 10 Posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION AND READ OTHER GREEK INFO:

How Democratic Was Athenian Democracy?

I’ve been studying the democracy of Athens lately, and I find it fascinating that such an influential system didn’t actually last very long in its original form. It’s often described as the birthplace of democracy, and yet when you look closely, it seems both groundbreaking and limited at the same time.

On the one hand, the idea of citizens participating directly in decision-making was radical. On the other hand, citizenship excluded women, enslaved people, and foreigners, which dramatically narrowed who had a voice. It makes me wonder how “democratic” it really was by its own standards, let alone ours.

I’m also curious how stable it truly felt at the time, given the political upheavals and eventual decline.

For those who’ve studied this period more deeply, how do you interpret Athenian democracy? Do you see it as a bold experiment that laid the groundwork for modern systems, or as something far more fragile and constrained?

Most forgotten period of Greek history?

I was in Crete once eating at a restaurant and there was a pile of artifacts heaped - broken pottery shards, etc. The restaurant told us that they were going to throw them out. I said, but they are artifacts, why?! They said that no one cares about that time period the artifacts came from - something about an Arabic occupation.

I thought it was interesting and it stayed with me nearly two decades later. This is clearly a forgotten period of Greek history. Does this happen a lot in Greece? Got me thinking about Greek history and what else may be forgotten... Would love your thoughts.

Period of Greek History You Find the Most Fascinating?

One of the things I love most about visiting Greece is how layered the history feels. You can be standing in one place and realize people have been living there for thousands of years across completely different eras.

So far, I’ve been especially drawn to Minoan history, places like Knossos really stayed with me, and also sites connected to the New Testament. Visiting locations tied to early Christianity adds a whole different dimension to travel for me.

Lately I’ve been thinking about planning future trips around specific historical periods, but Greece has so many that it’s hard to know where to focus next. Ancient classical sites, Byzantine monasteries, Ottoman-era towns, Venetian fortresses, it’s almost overwhelming in a good way.

I’d love to hear what periods of Greek history you personally find most fascinating, and why. Are there particular places that really brought that era to life for you? I’m looking for inspiration for future exploring.

ancient Greek circumflex: tilde vs. inverted breve

Apparently (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_diacritics) tilde and inverted breve are equivalent circumflex diacritics, but I have never come across the tilde in online ancient Greek texts. I would like to be able to type the inverted breve. The excellent program https://typegreek.com/ apparently does not allow this. Is there another program or procedure form doing this? Thanks in advance.

Why does the Battle of Thermopylae still capture so much attention?

The Battle of Thermopylae is one of those moments in Greek history that still seems to capture people's attention thousands of years later. The story of Leonidas and the small Greek force standing against the much larger Persian army has become a symbol of courage, sacrifice, and resistance against overwhelming odds.

Of course, the real history is more complicated than the legend, and Thermopylae was only one part of the larger Greco-Persian Wars. Still, there is something powerful about the idea of people choosing to hold their ground even when they know the outcome may not be in their favor.

I also think modern books, movies, and popular culture have helped keep the story alive, sometimes blending history with mythology. Why do you think the Battle of Thermopylae still fascinates people so much? Is it the history itself, the symbolism, or the legend that grew around it?
Share and discuss Greek history!

WorldwideGreeks.com is a free online forum community where people can discuss Greek food, travel, traditions, history and mythology.
Join Worldwide Greeks here!

JOIN COMMUNITY FOR FREE

LOGIN TO YOUR ACCOUNT
Back
Top